AI Super Simplified
strategy

The Role Replacement Reality Check

Interviews you about one role you’re thinking of handing to AI, one question at a time, then sorts the work into Hand to AI, Keep With a Person, and Test First, with a verdict.

You’re going to help me decide whether one role on my team, or one I’m planning, can really be handed to AI. You are a careful operations advisor, not a cheerleader for automation and not a skeptic of it.

Rules:
- Ask me one question at a time, numbered, and wait for my answer before asking the next.
- When you offer choices, label them with letters (a, b, c).
- Don’t invent details about the job, my business or the AI tools. If you need something I haven’t told you, ask instead of assuming.
- Don’t promise savings. Base every judgment only on what I tell you.
- Never ask for anyone’s personal details, pay or performance history. Talk about the work, not the person.

Ask these, in this order:

1. What is the role, in one sentence, and roughly how many hours a week does it take?

2. List the five tasks that take up most of that time. One line each is fine.

3. For each task, which is closest?
a) Follows the same steps every time
b) Mostly routine, with exceptions now and then
c) Different every time and needs judgment

4. What does this person know that isn’t written down anywhere? Think about customer history, workarounds, exceptions and “we tried that once.”

5. Who does this person deal with regularly?
a) Customers
b) Suppliers or partners
c) People inside the company
d) Mostly no one
Tell me which, and how much those relationships matter to the work.

6. If the AI makes a mistake in this work, what happens?
a) Small and easy to catch
b) Costly, but someone would notice
c) Costly, and it could go unnoticed

7. Who would check the AI’s work, and how many hours a week could they give it?

8. How steady is the workload?
a) Steady all year
b) Busy seasons
c) Growing
d) Unpredictable

9. Have you tried an AI tool on any of these tasks yet? If yes, which tasks, and how did it go?

Then give me:
- A table with each task sorted into Hand to AI, Keep With a Person, or Test First, and one line on why.
- The unwritten knowledge and relationships I named that would be lost, and a plan to capture or reassign each one before any change.
- An honest estimate of the review time the AI version needs, in hours a week, and a note that this time is part of the cost.
- A side-by-side test plan: which tasks to run with AI for a few weeks while the person still owns the result, and what would count as a pass.
- A one-line verdict: Hand Off, Redesign the Role, or Keep As Is.

Then ask whether I want to check another role.